Tell Me Why Achievements Guide 100%
This guide will be updated as soon as new chapters get released.
Chapters are divided into episodes which can be replayed via the main menu.
Missed collectibles can be cleaned up using isolated chapter replay.
The game features two main endings which depend on the interactions with Alyson and Tyler. You can either strenghten or weaken their bond.
Chapter 1: Homecoming
Episodes:
- Orphans
- Long Time No See
- The Crossing
- A Big Wooden House
- Bad Haircut
- Uninvited
- Rashomon
- To Serve And Protect
- Blood Oath
Collectibles:
- The Crafty Goblins
- The Mad Hunter
- The Wise Princess
- The Pious Pelican
- The Ice King
Story
Rear View Mirror
- Leave Fireweed Residential Center
Homecoming
- Enter the Ronan House
Bound To A Lie
- Remember the night the twins agreed to lie
Chapter One
- You completed Chapter One
Missable
This Is Despicable
- When we say locked, it’s locked
- Episode: A Big Wooden House
Try to open a locked door three times. The first locked door can be found at the barn:
We Need To Talk
- Take time to talk things over with your twin.
- Episode: A Big Wooden House
Sit down on any bench and have a chat with your twin. The first bench can be found in the backyard of the Ronan house:
Crafty Goblins
- Solve the puzzle on Mary-Ann’s door
- Episode: A Big Wooden House
Solution: Moose – Bear – Pelican:
Full Confession
- Make Tessa tell the twins everything she knows
- Episode: Rashomon
You must find two pieces of evidence in Tessa’s office:
- Use Tessa’s computer and read the e-mail “Alliance for Traditional Families”.
- Open the locker and read all pages of the notebook labeled “2004”.
Correct answers during the confrontation:
- October 2004
- You told her about the camp
- The Virtue Seekers Youth Camp
Hacking 101
- Find the password to unlock the Police Station computer
- Episode: To Serve And Protect
After receiving the keys from Eddy, enter the reception area and use the computer:
User: D. Wilson
Password: Salem
Collectibles
One For The Collection
- Find your first hidden Book of Goblins figure
- Note: Currently broken.
The Crafty Goblins
- Episode: Long Time No See
- Alyson: Story-related.
- Tyler: Story-related.
The Mad Hunter
- Episode: A Big Wooden House
- Tyler: While in the stack, find the “Here be dragons” poster and go to the right:
The Wise Princess
- Episode: A Big Wooden House
- Tyler: Next to the bed in Mary-Ann’s room:
The Pious Pelican
- Episode: Rashomon
- Alyson: Inside the locker in Tessa’s office:
The Ice King
- Episode: To Serve And Protect
- Alyson: In the police station – in the back of the interrogation room behind the kitchen:
Story
Chapter Two
- You completed Chapter Two
Missable
Twins4life
- Complete the story with the twins strongly bound together
Life Tears Us Apart
- Complete the story with the twin’s bond weakened
Collectibles
And Everything In Its Place
- Place all collectibles in the attic
To-do
Guess Who?
- Figure out who inspired each Book of Goblin character
- Note: Could be story-related; or you have to examine all animal figurines (e.g. frog).
Just One Fix
- Help Sam fix the engine
Are You My Daddy?
- Learn the truth about Sam’s relationship to the twins
A New Chapter
- Start writing a new chapter with Alyson
Cold Case
- Discover intel about Mary-Ann’s past and her death
Arborglyph
- Correct the old graffiti on the tree
Rest In Peace
- Make peace with Mary-Ann at the cemetery
Sharp Shooter
- Win the plush battle
State Your Emergency
- Find a recording of the twins’ 911 call
Fish all the Fish
- Catch all the fish with Michael
Kick Me
- Stick a post-it note in Tyler’s back
Lock-Up And Go
- Lock-up and leave the Ronan House with Tyler
Mailbox Bandit
- Find out who the Mailbox Bandit really is
The Princess’ Lost Treasure
- Uncover the princess’ lost treasure
Moo’d Changer
- Prove to Tyler that moo boxes are actually funny
Remember Strange Vampyr
- Find three classic posters
- Note: Probably easter eggs, Remember Me, Life is Strange and Vampyr.
