Red Dead Redemption 2 Help Tilly & Karen Walkthrough

1. Choice: Intervene or Defuse the argument between Tilly and a man.
2. Look for Karen in the Hotel near the Butcher.
3. Fight the drunk who hurt Karen.

1. Choose Between To Defuse or Intervene

Here, you will be given the choice to Defuse or Intervene in the argument between Tilly and a man. Choosing to Defuse will make the man walk away from Tilly saying “You’re making a big mistake, Tilly Jackson.”

2. Ask The Hotel Owner Where Karen Is

You can ask the Hotel Owner where Karen is to find her faster. The Hotel Owner will say that Karen is in the second floor, Room 2B.